I play private matches with a draft almost every night. Some characters are never picked. This is a list of characters that IMO needs buffs or tweaks. This is based on not many people playing these characters when a draft is in place.
Attikus- I have never played a competitive game with Attikus on either team. I actually love Attikus late game with his life steal, ult, etc. He needs some love though.
Whiskey Foxtrot- I think I’ve played one game with WF being picked. I have fun with WF, but I don’t think he is up to par with other gun/ranged characters. There are so many better options.
Caldarius- Caldarius is seldom picked up. I think he has a lot to offer, but gets out classed by Melka in pretty much every aspect, minus Cal’s ult. If Melka ever gets nerfed I think Cal would be in a good spot, but if not he needs a tiny touch of something to compete with her.
S&A- S&A is in a weird spot. Not tanky enough to be your main front line, not assassin enough to be your main CC/ganker. I don’t think S&A needs any buffs per say, but I think they could tweak her a little so she would fit in a role better. Make her more tanky, or make her do more damage, etc. Even if she is untouched, she’d still be good, but there are better characters out there for both the rolls she plays.
Deande- Deande never gets picked. I am master of Deande and actually love her playstyle, but most teams would rather another assassin/disruptor than Deande. Her uppercut is great and her ult can lead to team wipes if combo-ed with other team mates skills. Not sure what Deande needs but I think it’s something. Most teams would rather other characters than Deande in the role she fills.
Toby- Toby is in a tough spot as Marquis and Thorn are god tier in most comps. Thorn can shoot straight through the shield and Marquis can take it down very quickly. I don’t think this is the case of Toby being underpowered, but more so the other snipers being overpowered to a degree. In the current state of the game buffing Tobys ult might lead to him being picked up more, but teams will always want Marquis/Thorn first. They are just too game changing.
Again, this is based on playing private matches with a draft in Incursion. These characters are among the last picked or never picked. I made a post about the most banned/first picked characters and I just thought I’d make one on the opposite end of the spectrum as well.