Sledges Shotgun for nod to the original! THE LEGEND LIVES!
Maggie for the fact its badass!
I’m pretty sure you are the first one to say that in the entire world 
For Maya , I find the Florentine to be an amazing gun, when coupled with a good BoA and Legendary Cat COM. It can take almost anything down and I almost always have it equipped as a back up if nothing else. It’s just so versatile. Otherwise, I’d have to say the Pimp. Honourable mention goes to the White Death (elemental). Been using a Corrosive one with Zero and it rocks against anything armoured.
Also like the Thunderball Fists a lot. Just feels really good to use. So does the Hellfire and the Heartbreaker. The Hornet is an amazing gun but somehow doesn’t feel very nice: it’s more of a tool than anything else.
SWORDSPLOSION…because Mr Torgue said so…
I wish there was more dual-element weapons. 
The Nemesis from BL 1 was the best dule-element weapon in my opinion
Bekah
Pimpernel
Twister
Those are my top 3 in no real order
Hail
Kitten
Slowhand
Longbow
Coach Gun
Elephant Gun
Maggie
Butcher
Those might be tier 2, but it depends on my mood I guess
I looooove the Emperor. The tight pattern is great for shot placement, it kills efficiently, and I really enjoy the Dahl reload animation. I’ve yet to find one at OP8. Grrrr.
After that, I find these weapons to be very satisfying to use:
Never really played BL, (will get round to it once I upgrade my PC), but I have seen gameplay of that beast.
Also, what about that laser from pre-sequel?
Couldn’t agree more. As someone that plays hellborn and meat Krieg, those shotguns have INCREDIBLE DPS for me.
Also worth noting that a Practicable Thinking has higher close-range DPS than a Practicable CC, due to having that 1 extra projectile.
Just in case you didn’t know, in the original Borderlands you have to level up the different gun categories to make them more effective / do more damage. IIRC, the weapon level maxes out at 50. That is one of the things I didn’t like about the original Borderlands. However, if you have a weapon equipped (example: a Sniper Rifle) but aren’t actually shooting it you can still get exp towards increasing the Sniper category level if another player is shooting a Sniper Rifle.
Forum ID: Poisd2Strike
GT: Poisd2Strike
Trades: http://forums.gearboxsoftware.com/t/poisd2strikes-humble-shop/367700
Gun Prefixes | Gun Parts | Max Stats
Maya OP8 | Banshee RR / NRR | Binder | Cat | Nurse | Siren | Trickster B / M
@Poisd2Strike I knew about weapon proficiencies, I got to level 20something, but got bored on my own (360). But when I get a new G-card, I will start a new playthrough and level till the end. And thanks for telling me about that trick.
Can’t do without my Ladyfist
If it has to be only one overall choice, then it would be the Bitch. Coupled with the right setup it’s deadly enough for close-quarters work, fast enough for quick moving or small enemies, and as accurate as any sniper rifle out there. Only thing better would be if that Bitch made a great cup of coffee too.
It’s a bitch to farm tho…
True it’s not the most enjoyable farm, but with Maya and a corrosive Pimp with crit bonus it’s not a particularly difficult farm either. I did get 2 Bitches, a fire Leech, an Axton head, and a Sham in less than 25 attempts… that’s pretty good for BNK3R.
The Slow Hand as my favorite, with Maggie, Greed and Snider following. I also have a soft spot for the Good/Bad touch and Lascaux, I used those a lot back then.
The Slow Hand is like a small rocket launcher, and proves to be even better when everyone you play with lives far and the lag makes aiming difficult. The Pimpernel is a great upgrade to the Snider, but the Snider feels more natural to me.
I don’t remember what platform you play Borderlands 2 on, but if you are on PC, Xbox One or PS4 you might want to consider using a Blurred Trickster + Chain Reaction + Pimpernel (Corrosive) + Bone of the Ancients (Corrosive) when farming BNK3R as Maya. It is possible for Maya (and Zer0) to “one-shot” BNK3R on those platforms (even at OP8), without even using a Bee shield (although it certainly helps). That should make your BNK3R farming runs a bit easier 
Forum ID: Poisd2Strike
GT: Poisd2Strike
Trades: http://forums.gearboxsoftware.com/t/poisd2strikes-humble-shop/367700
Gun Prefixes | Gun Parts | Max Stats
Maya OP8 | Banshee RR / NRR | Binder | Cat | Nurse | Siren | Trickster B / M
I agree with what you said about the Snider. I dislike the Pimpernel, it doesn’t behave like a sniper, which defeats the whole point of using one.
Well, you must not play 360. I can’t farm him at all, he glitches out every 2 runs, manages to fly away with smallest amount of health, and I just find killing him aggravating as hell. His drop rates however aren’t bad at all,I got a 93% Sham second try once.