Favorite Pop Tart Flavors

A work associate and I have been having a lively discussion about this. Apparently s’mores and various fudge flavors are very popular- which surprises us because we consider both varieties to be garbage time flavors made by mad men (unless you freeze smores, then they become very good). Right now our top 3 would probably be Cinnamon and Brown Sugar (frosted of course, we’re not goddamned heathens), Frosted Cherry, and the limited edition Pumpkin Pie, although our orders vary greatly.

Thoughts on this heated debate?

1 Like

Pumpkin Pie sounds damned good…


My top 3 in no particular order…:

  • Brown Sugar/Cinnamon (frosted)
  • Strawberry (unfrosted)
  • Wild Berry

We don’t have that stuff here xD

The most similar thing could be toasted bread with butter or marmalade

Strawberry (frosted).

2 Likes

I want pumpkin pie pop tarts. Sadness is feeling me.

My favorites are
Brown sugar
Oatmeal
Peanut butter

2 Likes

I HATE poptarts.

2 Likes

I agree. I would not agree if there was a pumpkin pie flavour however… :wink:

There is apparently and I want them

2 Likes

Equally hated is pumpkin. All gourds, actually. And most melons.

1 Like

Leaves thread

3 Likes

just threw up in my mouth a little.

1 Like

is apple and cinnamon one? think that’s what we used to have.
I haven’t had them since they stopped being sold here many moons ago.

1 Like

Frosted strawberry. I just eat them straight out of the package. Screw heating them up.

3 Likes

Same here. I also like frosted cherry.

2 Likes

@Poisonedbite @Piemanlee @nathanielmattock

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/71ZPe9mpL8L.SL1000.jpg

I refuse for my integrity to be called into question.

Also what is with the frosted strawberry lust? Its like, the generic pop tart.

4 Likes

So? That doesn’t mean we can’t like it. :stuck_out_tongue:

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/71ZPe9mpL8L.SL1000.jpg
http://31.media.tumblr.com/d6c6a9e8a672e31b942106e725765ffd/tumblr_nlsofcZ3751u8zsalo1_500.gif

2 Likes

I want them with a side of cool whip.

2 Likes

image

1 Like

Just found it, picked it up because of this thread. Pumpkin Pie sounds is damned good; on paper, might go good with some hot chocolate.

1 Like