I’m pretty sure the Company Man lost out to the Thinking because…
- the Thinking has better damage (~13%) and slightly more accuracy.
- The Thinking is farm-able legitimately.
- And has access to massive DPS increasing glitches, which Jack is very good at taking advantage of.
- The one bonus the company man provides is a massive magazine increase, but since Jack has access to ‘Just Compensation’ and especially ‘Absolute Advantage’ the mag size is just overkill. So in the end the you’d prefer the better damage the Thinking has, and even more so if it’s a glitch variant.
P.S. I think I remember that the Thinking and CM have the same vertical type spread, the person that did the wiki probably just never paid attention to a Thinking’s spread before.