I love it. BL2’s over the top zaniness is right up my alley, for my liking it’s the funniest game I’ve ever played (the similarly idiotic Saints Row 3 takes 2nd spot, seems like there’s a pattern). What sets it further apart is the stellar voice acting, again among the best of any game I’ve ever played. Its humour is a major reason why I love this game so much.
BL1 (main game) pales in comparison, it’s got some funny stuff but it’s nowhere near BL2. Also it often doesn’t seem to know if it wants to be funny or not, maybe a result of its change of direction late in development. The DLCs were a big step up.
TPS however, its humour (or in my opinion, lack thereof) was the most disappointing thing about the entire game to me. I think it made me chuckle 3 or 4 times in the entire game, the rest of the time I didn’t find it funny at all. Nurse Nina is a very poor replacement for Dr. Zed, Pickle is an abysmal one for Tiny Tina. And perhaps worst of all, Handsome Jack was hugely disappointing. He was extremely good in BL2, I couldn’t get enough of his comments, but in TPS he’s just not funny at all and I wish he’d just stop talking.
So that’s actually been my biggest concern for BL3, that it would fall short in this regard again. However the footage seen so far seems alright–if maybe not quite up there with BL2–so since the gameplay reveal I can sleep at night again.