Disclaimer: I think battleborn is twice as good as overwatch at it’s best
Opinion: overwatch is gonna kill battleborn. It doesn’t matter if they aren’t the same game, when competitive multiplayer games compete for the money in your wallet at the exact same time one is going to beat out the other (have to get a solid player base early which is borderline impossible when a better alternative is released almost simultaneously).
Rationale: battleborn has a terribly bland campaign and a very bad multiplayer mode in meltdown. With only two maps in incursion (and I guess two for the other mode but I dunno), the experience is way too lean for a 60 dollar game (with most likely maps coming as paid dlc). On top of this the matchmaking is horrendous. Too slow to get into games and when you do get in people drop out and you are stuck down a man or waiting through an entire match for the next one. Plus, squads aren’t evened out in terms of level making it extremely unlikely to ever get balanced teams (unless you form a party and wreck).
Solution: two possiblities, both which suck for you guys at gearbox, but at least one needs to happen to save this gem before it gets obliterated. 1) fix the freaking matchmaking right meow. Halo on last gen consoles had better matchmaking than this bull crap. The speed in which you get into matches for overwatch are almost too fast (sometimes in 5-10 seconds). 2) drop the price. This game right now isn’t worth 60 dollars (or the 100 or whatever for the bogus extra skins for that matter). This needs to be at most 40 to match overwatch, although with how bad matchmaking is and lack of multiplayer maps it is really worth less than that when compared to overwatch.
I want to play this game, I really freaking do, but I don’t want to sit and watch a loading screen for an hour and think to myself “why did I spend 60 bucks for nothing” while I pass the time playing hearthstone and get ready to boot up overwatch.