I have an Xbox One X, I am playing from a 360 disc version of BL1 splitscreen. I am unable to select a profile for player 2. It is always a level 1 character without the ability to log in with a user profile. The option is not there at all to select anything but guest. In game, when you go to splitscreen, I am able to select player one profile, but when player two activates their controller there is not an option, it goes straight to guest and the notice that progress will not be saved.
I have tried both options of the Player 2 controller being logged in or out of the profile we are trying to use. Does anyone else have this issue? If someone else has had this issue, or has figured this out, please feel free to chime in.
I am trying to keep with the exact console/player set up as I just introduced BL1 to my daughter and we had such a blast playing together and we were pretty bummed that we lost all that progress on her character. Just bought the XB1X and don’t want to go back to 360 after getting a new console.