Would it be possible to bind the penalty to the quit command in the menu? Have a pop up come up saying “Quitting will put a [insert time duration] hold for queing to a new match on you. Do you still want to quit?”
That could help prevent true discos from being penalized. Then when you get back on and requeue, if the match is still going it gives you the option to rejoin (like it does now) with the note that if you choose “No” you will have a queue hold placed on you.
That still doesn’t address the edge case of people just closing the game.
People will just close down the game. The system you’re referring to is exactly what The Last of Us has, and people simply close app all the time.
So how do you tell who the rage quitters are, and who the people are like me who have a small baby or child and you gotta leave because one starts crying or something.
Would you rather me leave and another player come in to help or just set my controller down and be afk?
It does if the match is still ongoing. Otherwise, your right. However no fix is going to completely solve this and I’d rather let the really determined get away with it then punish the undeserving.
Thanks for all your input guys. When i think of a good penalty system i think of sm4sh, (or at least the 3ds version idk about the wii u), where it can tell which connection error is a rage quit i.e. closing the system and a genuine bad connection. I feel like this can be done for BB but i’m no developer and don’t know how feasible that would be
In Heroes Of The Storm, when a player leaves their character is replaced by a bot. And when you leave, you get a penalty - you can only join a match with other leavers, until you’ve played through one match without leaving it. I think in the ranked mode you also get time penalties for leaving the game? I haven’t played ranked personally yet, though.
I think how rage quitters are handled in HOTS is excellent.
HotS bots are just feeding the enemies with EXP though. This one will feed even harder.
This game needs to do both what the OP stated and to give people more reason to not quit.
You rage quit or DC? You aren’t allowed to play for X minutes, increasing by Y% every time you leave, counter reset at a certain day at certain time in certain time zone or if you play enough games. (So if you rage quit 5 times today, you end up suffering for it for a whole week)
For those who continue until the end, you earn a certain point that increase how much credit/exp you earn at the end of the game.
Winning the game gives you 3 points.
Losing the game gives you 1 point (so you gain something for playing till the end)
Surrendering before A minutes give you no points. (So no surrender spam)
Leaving a game and not returning, whether by DC or intentional, reset the point.
For each point, you get +1% credit and EXP, up to 50 points for +50%.
Less and less benefit to rage quit
Not if you actually cme back and play properly on later games.
Hm, I forgot to word my post properly! Sorry about that! I was telling what happens in HOTS when a player leaves, so decided to include the added bot player. The bots absolutely suck, I am definitely not calling that excellent! But being forced into a leaver queue is an excellent penalty in my opinion.
Pretty sure that count as a game fail and does nothing to even the game record.
Fail game like this should be treated like DotA cases. DotA has a lot of checkmark before a match can really be registered as an actual match.
Anyone having absolutely horrid ping at the start? IF so. MAtch canceled. Everyone can leave. Not recorded
Anyone DC’d at the start? IF so. Match canceled.
IS the server having issues? If so. Match canceled.
Although it shows as DC, it doesn’t count. If it doesn’t, this is an issue with the game coding itself treating DC and match fail as the same thing, when it shouldn’t. However, there is no match ID anyway and you cannot view the failed game in your match history. This likely means the match is canceled and there is no penalty/reward being handled.
Leaver penalty is already a thing anyway because even if it’s by accident since other people are also harmed by this. Some game even hand you a temp ban if you dc up to X time in Y amount of games. (LoL Leaverbuster)
Better Idea, Quitter forfiet half of their max credit. They are going to suffer like the rest of use.
in story mode i ran into a guy (or gal, he/she was playing montana) that threw himself outside the map, and when we tried to revive him, he had already pressed the respawn button, then he appeared, and threw himself again and respawned, and he got all the remaining lives, and then he disconected. maybe it was a troll but that kind of people DOES need a punishment, because everyone left the game and then it means we all get punished. and that plain sucks.
I know it’s annoying but its just one of necessary evils of playing online with randoms. If you start instituting these harsh penalties you would just create matchmaking problems. It’s hard enough to find a match. This game already has huge potential to go sweaty, so much so people already leave matchmaking when a low level player joins.
Also, I think it would really be a kick in the balls to have you internet drop and then be unable to play for two hours. Also penalizing the player would just hurt the team they are on as a whole.
NO. Here’s the best way to fix leavers. The current system is close to how it should be by not allowing the “leaver” to enter another MP match or even do Story (that was smart GBX).
Just want to comment on the idlers.
I had a number of instances where someone would put up a vote to surrender…sometimes after only 2-3 minutes. (I pretty much played meltdown exclusively)
And when the vote came in as ‘No’ they would just idle in the base camp. Presumably to just get the game over with more quickly by not providing any sort of support.
I guess I just don’t understand the mentality of giving up after a couple of minutes because you’re playing with randoms and go against what looks to be a party…and you see that you probably won’t win. Even if you’re not going to win the match, you should still be playing to your characters strengths. (Kill players, Kill minions, build deployables, farm shards, ect.)
Anyway, it would be great if someone could be done for idlers, especially the ones who are sabotaging the match because they want it to be over with.
i noticed this too! im like, " ok i get you guys, we are pretty outmatched so lets surrender just to save time. ok. come on guys. seriously?! just hit surrender already! your are literally doing nothing (ocassional jumping too so i know they are there)" -_-
for something like this. a in game system to rate players be nice
good idea, ill also add newcomers can get xp bonus to the median of what their team is so they can be on par with everyone in there lvl
also the game already has a idle check. in story mod if i was idle for 1-2 mins i got a warning i was idle. so im assuming idle people get kicked