Title: Play Balancing Mod for HWRM
Discussion: [TOOL] Play Balancing Mod for HWRM v2.3.0 (new)
This gamerule iterates through a list of ships, comparing the performance of
one ship versus the performance of another. Using this method, one can gauge to
some degree of accuracy the relative combat strength of each ship versus the
Extract the ZIP archive and copy the “DataPlayBalancingHWRM” folder to your
"Homeworld Remastered" directory. You will also need to edit your command line
in order to get the mod to work properly. This is described in a later section.
This mod is a singleplayer campaign made up of only one level. The game starts
with one aggressive CPU player attacking a completely passive CPU opponent. You
then iterate through all of Player 2’s ships until they all have been defeated.
Next, you iterate to Player 1’s next ship and reset Player 2 to his first ship,
repeating the cycle. When all of Player 1’s ship have defeated all of Player
2’s ships, the game ends and the results are printed to the log, or to another
file on the disk.
The goal is to compare the time it takes for Player 1’s ship to defeat Player
2’s ship with the time it took for Player 2’s ship to defeat Player 1’s ship.
The less time it takes, the more powerful the ship. Some ships don’t have any
weapons at all and are skipped.
A value of “NoAttack” means that one or both ships have no offensive weapon and
therefore cannot attack. A value of “TimedOut” means that one or both ships ran
out of time before killing all of the opponent’s ships. Currently the timeout
value is 1 hour. A value of “SameShip” means that the Left and Top Ships are
identical, and therefore equal in strength. A value of “Failed” means the
calculation has gone wrong somewhere and needs to be fixed.
You’re going to have to modify your command-line in order to get the mod to
run. See the section, below, for an example command-line. Note, that Players 1
and 2 will be doing the actual fighting. You (Player 0) will merely be playing
the part of observer. Simply let the game run until it is finished, and it will
exit by itself. If you run out of memory first, or if the game should stall for
some other reason, just quit the game and modify the configuration settings in
"PlayBalancing_Config.lua" so that you can start right where you left off. Make
sure to check “HwRM.log” for the results of the previous tests so that you can
copy them to somewhere safe. Otherwise, they will be overriden and you will
have to start over from scratch.
While running the game you will see some text on the screen:
• Index: the place in the global ShipList table that each ship occupies.
• Count: the place in the current processing queue that each ship occupies.
• Alive: the number of alive ships belonging to Player 1 and Player 2.
• Health: the health of each player’s fleet as a percentage of full health.
• Ships: Player 1 and Player 2’s ship types.
• Research1: Player 1’s researches.
• Research2: Player 2’s researches.
• Round Time: the elapsed time in the current mini-battle.
• Game Time: the elapsed time since the start of game according to the game.
• World Time: the elapsed time since the start of game in real time.
• Display Text: a custom message set in “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• Script Version: the current version of the Play Balancing script.
Game Time and World Time will be different from each other if you start the
game with the -superTurbo command line switch enabled. Otherwise, they should
OUTPUT LOG FILE
The script outputs the results of each mini-battle to a new line in “HwRM.log”.
At the end of the game, it also outputs all the cumulative stats to a file
called “PBAL_Results.txt” in your player profile directory. If you exit the
game early, or if the game crashes, this output file will not be written and
you will need to piece together what happened by examining the individual lines
Here are what the individual fields in the generated output mean:
• P1_ShipNumber: the index number of player 1’s ship in ShipList.
• P1_ShipsLeft: the number of player 1’s ships left over at the end of a round.
• P1_AvgHealth: the average health of player 1’s ships (including dead ones) at
the end of a round.
• P1_ShipType: the type of player 1’s ship.
• P1_ResearchList: any research items applied to player 1’s ships.
• P2_ShipNumber: the index number of player 2’s ship in ShipList.
• P2_ShipsLeft: the number of player 2’s ships left over at the end of a round.
• P2_AvgHealth: the average health of player 2’s ships (including dead ones) at
the end of a round.
• P2_ShipType: the type of player 2’s ship.
• P2_ResearchList: any research items applied to player 2’s ships.
• RoundTime: the duration of the battle between player 1 and player 2’s ships.
Or a flag indicating why the duration of the battle was not recorded.
• ExtraTime: the amount of time it would take (probably) for Player 1 to kill
Player 2 if time were allowed to continue past “TimeOutValue”. If none of
Player 2’s ships are left alive, or if all of Player 2’s ships are at 100%
health, then “ExtraTime” will equal “RoundTime”.
THE COMMAND LINE
You will need to edit your command line settings in order to run this mod. This
mod is a singleplayer mod, not multiplayer, so you will need to set the correct
campaign and starting level in the command line. At the very least, you should
use the following flags:
"%HWRM%\Bin\Release\HomeworldRM.exe" -moddatapath DataPlayBalancingHWRM -campaign PlayBalancing -startingLevel testlevel -overrideBigFile -luaTrace -superTurbo -quickLoad
The -superTurbo switch is probably the most important of these, as it allows
you to speed up the game by a factor of about 50. Without it, this sort of
testing would require unbearably long periods of time. It is also handy to run
teh game in a window using the -windowed switch to make the ALT+TAB between
The -quickLoad switch used to be important when running Homeworld 2 Classic,
but I don’t think it works for Homeworld Remastered any more.
STARTING THE GAME FROM A BATCH FILE
If, like me, you start running out of space in the “Target” field of your
desktop shortcut, you can start the game from a batch file. Here is what one of
my batch files looks like:
HomeworldRM.exe -overrideBigFile -luatrace -hardwareCursor -w 800 -h 600 -windowed -ssTGA -moddatapath DataPlayBalancingHWRM -freeMouse -traceHODs -nosound -noMovies -quickLoad -campaign playbalancing -startinglevel testlevel -superTurbo -logfilename=%HWRM%\Bin\Release\HwRM_left.log
The first line switches to the E:\ drive, since that is where I have Homeworld
Remastered installed. The second line switches the current working directory
to the “Release” folder, which contains the game’s executable. The game won’t
start unless you do this first! The third line actually starts the game using
the command line switches you have selected. I actually use more switches than
you see above, since I run multiple instances of the game, and need the game to
write to separate log files. The last line pauses the command prompt window so
that it doesn’t disappear right away. If the game quits and there are error
messages, they will appear in the command prompt window.
Note that %HWRM% is an environmental system variable. You can create these
variables to store frequently used strings of text, such as paths to files and
folders that you work on frequently. Here are some instructions on how to use
and set up environmental variables:
These instructions should be applicable to most versions of MS Windows.
Remember that research is cumulative. This means that once it’s been granted,
it will remain in effect until the game ends. To compensate for this you can
test ships in blocks by modifying the starting and ending points for each
player. The ship list, as well as other modifiable values, is stored in
"PlayBalancing_Config.lua" in your “DataPlayBalancingHWRM” directory. Note that
there may be a delay of a few seconds between some rounds, as non-combat-
capable ships are skipped when pitted against other non-combat-capable ships.
Battles will also time-out after 1 hours (game-time).
If you’re modifying this mod for your own purposes, remember to remove any
spawned salvage from within the .ship files. Search each .ship file for
commands that start with “SpawnSalvageOnDeath” and delete those lines. This is
necessary in order to keep the game from slowing to a crawl, and hunks of
salvage from getting in the way of weapons fire. Further, the salvage hunks use
If you only run the game in small batches instead of all ships battling all
other ships, you decrease the likelyhood of the game crashing due to lack of
memory. Remember that Homeworld Remastered is a 32-bit application, and thus
can only address a few gigabytes of RAM. On my computer, the game crashes after
about 200 mini-battles, but consider that just one Vaygr vs. Hiigaran campaign
consists of over 1500 mini-battles. If you have a lot of RAM and multiple CPU
cores, you can run multiple instances of the game. This is described in the
If the game crashes, you may be able to recover the stats that have accumulated
up to that point and edit them by hand.
RUNNING MULTIPLE INSTANCES OF THE MOD
If you have plenty of RAM and a multi-core CPU, then you can run multiple
instances of Homeworld Remastered. Obviously, this will speed up your tests
considerably. In order to keep track of which instance is doing what, I added
the following code to my copy of “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”:
SetMeUp = 0
if (SetMeUp == 0) then
DisplayText = "Left"
Player1Race = "hiigaran"
Player1Start = 31
Player1End = 35
Player2Race = "hiigaran"
Player2Start = 1
Player2End = nil
DisplayText = "Right"
Player1Race = "vaygr"
Player1Start = 30
Player1End = 33
Player2Race = "vaygr"
Player2Start = 1
Player2End = nil
I then switch between instances by editing the “SetMeUp” variable. For
instance, when I have two instances running, one is on the left side of my
screen, and one is on the right side of my screen. The code above keeps the
two instances from stepping on each others’ toes.
You’re free to use this code in any way as long as proper credit is given for
the work that I have done.
• Some units will not pursue a target while attacking, or will run away when
their health falls too low. These should not be tested against each other. In
"PlayBalancing_Config.lua", you should give these ships a “CanAttack” value
of zero. I’m not sure what to do with marine frigates, however. It does have
offensive weapons, but still runs away from ships such as the ion turret.
The scout likewise will run away from a mothership.
• Maybe I should allow “AB_UseSpecialWeaponsInNormalAttack”. I’m not really
sure, though, what this does, exactly.
• I must find a more convenient way of making research non-cumulative (e.g.
turning researches on/off via scripting).
• If both players have the same ship and that ship has the Capture Abilty, then
a player may end up with more ships than he/she started out with. This only
happens when the “EnableSpecialAbility” setting is turned on.
• If the game is running for a long enough time, it will start to run out of
memory due to the number of ships and salvage. That’s why running the mod in
small batches and deleting all “SpawnSalvageOnDeath” commands from .ship
files is so important!
• It would be great if you could see all of the ships’ health bars at once
instead of having to click on each individual ship. This is the default
behavior for ships that belong to you, but does not work for allies or
enemies. Need to find some way of making it work with other players’ ships
• The game now writes two sets of files to disk: a normal set and a
"temporary" set. Are both necessary? Would it be okay to just stick with the
• The blast radius of large ships like the mothership may be obliterating
strike craft in the next round. Have to maybe extend the delay between
• The “Auto Reload” feature is very complicated, so I suggest not using it. I’m
also not going to document it until I feel better about how it is designed.
• The “CalcTime” or “ExtraDuration” parameters do not take into account Player
1’s health, unfortunately. This means they should be ignored in rounds where
both Player 1 and Player 2 can take damage
2.3.0 — 2016/08/12
• Removed the “AutoReloadInterval” parameter from “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
Since the positive aspects of having it are not that great (simplicity,
saving a little time), and the negative aspect (higher memory usage) is
pretty big, I decided to axe the feature. That memory can be better spent
running additional instances of HWRM in parallel.
• Player 1 and Player 2 now share vision completely. In the past, sometimes a
lone straggler would get lost in a corner of the map and the game would go on
forever and ever. Hopefully this fixes that problem for good.
• Added a short message for when you’ve completed all rounds for a particular
set of races and it’s time to switch races and start over.
• Some tweaks to the “AutoReload” feature allowing the mod to pick up after it
left off in case of a crash, even midway through Player 2’s list of ships.
The script is now able to record Player 2’s status, and write it to disk
after every battle instead of after every round.
• The game now also records each player’s race as part of the "AutoReload"
• Health percentages are now calculated for all 10 ships, not just the
remaining alive ones.
• Added the “ExtraTime” and “ExtraDuration” parameters. They are used to extra-
polate how long it would take (probably) for Player 1 to kill Player 2’s
ships if the round time were allowed to proceed past the timeout value. These
numbers are derived from the health of any of Player 2’s ships that are still
alive when “TimeOutValue” is reached. If no ships are left alive, or if all
the ships are at 100% health, then “ExtraTime” will equal “RoundTime”.
2.2.0 — 2016/08/09
• Started to implement a method of reading and writing to output files so you
can continue on where you left off if the game crashes. This is enabled by
the “AutoReloadFlag” setting, but is experimental and tricky to manage. Be
careful when using this setting!
• The new “AutoReload” feature is very complicated, so I suggest not using it.
I’m not going to document it until I feel better about how it is designed.
• The mod now writes stats to a temporary file in case the game crashes and you
have to launch the game again. You will have to clean up these files manually
when done using them since they are not deleted automatically by the mod. The
mod also now no longer prints to “HWRM.log”.
• The “DisplayText” variable is now used for generating the
"NextIteration_.lua" file in the player profile directory. This file is
used in conjunction with the “AutoReloadFlag” setting to permit you to
restart the mod after a game crash, and is no longer merely cosmetic.
• You can now skip a round and move on to the next ship by pressing the "P"
key. This causes the round to be marked “Skipped” in the log files. Do this
when the health percentages are both stuck at 100% or thereabouts.
• Increased the default round duration to 2 hours instead of 1.
• Added the “ScriptVersion” parameter to help keep myself organized.
• Increased the amount of time between ending the last round and starting the
new one. This was because motherships’ splash damage upon death was killing
• You can now see the health percentage each player’s ships on the screen.
• The game now periodically reminds Player 1 and Player 2 to attack each other.
This was in response to ships losing sight or running away from each other.
The real solution for the former may be to give each player perfect vision
across the whole map. Not sure how to do this, though.
• Added a “Please wait” message between rounds so that players know not to quit
the game when the action pauses.
2.1.1 — 2016/08/07
• Added spaces around commas in research lists.
• Created a new variable called “MakeImmobile”. Player 2’s ships will now move
about as per normal game behavior when attacked unless this setting is
enabled. If enabled, the setting causes Player 2’s ships to sit still in a
completely passive state. This setting is disabled by default.
2.1.0 — 2016/08/05
• Added the “DisplayText” variable so now you can print some arbitrary text to
the screen to stay organized.
• Added an example of running multiple instances of the mod and game to the
• Updated the documentation with additional tips.
• Placed the time duration measurements and display text at the start of the
output file instead of the end.
• The printed output file names are now numbered to make it easier to tell at a
glance what they contain.
• The script was ignoring the research list when determining whether two ships
were the “same” or not.
• The script now properly detects whether you have specified values for
Player1End and Player2End that are greater than the length of the ship lists.
• Other minor tweaks.
2.0.0 — 2016/08/02
• Updated the mod to work with Homeworld Remastered instead of Homeworld 2
Classic. This includes the game rule and the “ShipList” table in
• The entries for each race in the “ShipList” table now use text identifiers
instead of numerical identifiers.
• Lots of tweaks to ATI display output.
• Lowered the “TimeOutValue” variable to 1 hours. If it takes longer than this
amount for ships to kill each other, then the ships are not worth tracking.
• The mod now also writes cumulative stats to a text file in the player profile
directory. However, this only happens if the game doesn’t crash (or you don’t
quit) before the mod finishes its task.
• Renamed the .level file and mission from “Mission_01” to “testlevel”.
• The script now skips battles if either player’s ship does not have an
offensive capability, not just Player 1’s ship.
• Removed the “SkipDuplicates” parameter. The mod now automatically skips
battles where both players’ ships are identical. I may add this feature again
in the future, because I’m not sure removing it was the best choice.
• Fixed a bug where Players 1 and 2 were being assigned the wrong races in the
level file due to the “player” table having been idexed improperly.
• Player 2’s move ability is now deactivated when Player 1 is set to being
• Other minor tweaks.
1.2.0 — 2009/03/30
• Fixed an error in “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• The ShipList table in “PlayBalancing_Config.lua” has been collapsed,
reordered and extended.
• You can now specify a list of research items to be granted, instead of just a
• The mod now works properly if the “MakeInvulnerable” parameter is set to 1
(it was broken).
• Changed the rule names.
• Gun, ion and missile platforms now have their “CanAttack” setting set to 1.
• All platforms are now set as deployed.
• The number of ships that may be spawned can now be specified individually for
each type of ship.
• Added the “EnableSpecialAbility” parameter to “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• Added the “NumberOfPoints” parameter to “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• Renamed the “DistanceBtwUnits” parameter to “DistanceBtwPoints”.
• The map now generates positions for each ship in the form of a cube instead
of a sphere.
1.1.0 — 2005/03/03
• Fixed an error in “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• All platforms now have their “CanAttack” setting set to zero.
• Changed several parameters in “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• Added the “MakeInvulnerable” parameter to “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• Added the “TimeOutValue” parameter to “PlayBalancing_Config.lua”.
• Removed the background image and music from the map to speed things up a bit
and cut down on memory usage.
• Increased the delay between rounds to 5 seconds to allow time for errant
missiles to fade away.
• Now checks whether any ships have been captured, and then destroys those
• Now reports the total health percentage of the remaining ships.
• Changed the mod to a singleplayer campaign instead of a multiplayer gametype.
• Removed spawned salvage from the .ship files. This is necessary in order to
keep memory usage down to a minimum.
• Added an ATI display showing the current round, the remaining ships and a
timer for the current round (in seconds).
• Ships are now destroyed at the end of each round instead of despawned (uses
• Set the AI difficulty to level 1 instead of the default level 0.
• Other fixes.
1.0.0 — 2005/02/25
• Initial release.