We get it, but chill on the “representation” in video games

No I live a fine life, your missing the point buddy

Thank you my guy, it’s totally force fed

1 Like

Yeah, I don’t believe this at all. I mean for that to be valid they would have to ignore well basically Africa, most of the Asian continent, most of the non coastal USA, Mexico, and judging from some of the fights I’ve been in for implying that someone prefer to catch instead of pitching most Latin countries as well.

For that to be true, they would have to ignore what people say. There would have to be testing on how people respond to what images and sounds (heart rate, pupil dilation, sequential blood draws lots of physiological stuff); not just write down how they think they feel about it or what they want to admit.

And some of this stuff was studied (like that) a looong time ago; it came up when I was in debate in High School and that was in the 70’s.

There are lots of unpopular study results that get buried. People like to crow about how drug use by the mother during pregnancy can negatively effect a child. But what we don’t tend to hear about are the stuff from the 60’s (or maybe older) which noted that drug/alcohol consumption by the father before conception can also cause damage.

Just wanting to point out that “not agreeing” or “not liking it” doesn’t make things not true.

And none of this means anyone has to act any certain way. If you don’t want to “do this or that” then don’t. It’s all good.

1 Like

No. I get what you are saying, but no.

That study is saying that only 4% of the population identifies as single sex persuasion wether it be hetero or homosexual. (Edit: added sexual to homosexual as it’s a 4 letter word with out it.)

It’s wrong or highly skewed.

4 Likes

So you’re looking for a strong male leader, eh? Nudge nudge, wink wink, say no more.

6 Likes

Yeah that’s not right. I don’t recall where I read it off the top of my head but almost half are female, they have a very large LGBT following, is huge in the Latin community (which makes it even worse that there is no fricken Truxican).

Your way of on that one mate.

1 Like

I hate you for that comment but congrats you got me :joy:

2 Likes

My thoughts on this are pretty simple.

‘Diversity’ is neither a good nor a bad thing. Movies and games have always been pretty damn diverse, regardless of what the current political zeitgeist would tell you. There is definitely a fad right now, based on …well, essentially a Cargo Cult fallacy that movies and games must be diverse, or be filleted by woke-scolding publications and pundits.

This has resulted in some movies and games crowbarring in diversity for diversity’s sake, to their detriment.

Borderlands 3 is not one of those games. It never attempts to push any political message (aside from perhaps a tangentical prod at caster culture and religion). The Fl4k thing is a little silly…but never intrudes on the game or becomes preachy. Ditto the gay romance. Ditto the majority of main characters being female. It’s neither something I enjoy or dislike, and the game is good enough for it not to matter one iota.

If you want to look at a game that is one of those games, Wolfenstein: The New Colossus is probably a good example.

Most people don’t care about what shape their avatar in the game takes - because until quite recently, most characters weren’t even human. We care about a good game. As much as I love a good political discussion, taking a swipe at BL3, a game with exploding heads, meatcycles and giant guns for being ‘PC’ is daft.

If people want to make their games ‘inclusive’, I’ll probably roll my eyes - but as long as it’s a good game, I don’t care.

7 Likes

Yeah, the wife and I have gone over that (and similar) studies and they …tend to be rather bad. Statistical trickery, limited sample sizes, leading questions and classifications designed to obtain the outcome the author wants.

I’d be happy to walk anyone who wants to know why through the study of their choice.

2 Likes

Honestly, I never really noticed. The characters are well written and engaging enough that their gender isn’t all that big a consideration.

That said - the game is really, really missing Handsome Jack.

A study that has been pretty much debunked several times over now. If it’s the one I think you are talking about, it basically skewed it’s classification criteria to ensure the result it was trying to get.

Feel free to link it here or hit me up via PMs, and I’ll go through it’s methodological faults in detail.

1 Like

Borderlands is a severely dysfunctional universe and that is what got me into it. It could be argued it does not go far enough with representing a wide range of human behaviors. If it weren’t for the comedic element, this franchise would be ridiculously dark.

I saw someone mention my favorite character in the franchise, Brick, as being cis male. Given how absolutely bloody his existence is, I wouldn’t be surprised if he had a disturbing kink. Writers can make of the characters what they will, but identifying with any of the characters is just funny to me. About the furthest I will identify with a character is their principles.

Same goes for the entire cast, really. None of them are “normal”, so expecting anything consistent with a cross-section of the real world is asking way too much. Nobody should be looking at the Borderlands universe as a model for how you want to build a healthy society, so why does representation matter?

Unless, of course, the writers want to retcon the death of Joe Gamerski. That might be the most accurate model for a certain kind of Borderlands player. (Sarcasm)

2 Likes

Just an FYI thought on this is I feel like people are not giving consideration that in this future most people are more open minded and no longer have a single gender attraction making the norm being bisexual?

2 Likes

I’d love to see your data on this.

Also - are you implying that sexual orientation is a choice, and not biological? I think people may disagree with you on that one.

Ohh shazz, you’re right. Got that all muddled up.

Hey I dig the way Moze looks.

The one thing I kind of don’t really care for these days is this idea that being more progressive/open-minded=being more attracted to the same sex as well. It doesn’t work like that.

2 Likes

Come on.
It’s a game… from the dawn of time games where only about “strong white straight males”.
I am a bisexual male and i didn’t even noticed it. hell, MOST PEOPLE didn’t even notice it.

I think this post is just because you wanted a reaction from non-straight people.
this post is not even about the point you make because of the simple fact that if it was actually because you wanted more straight characters in this BL (a fair point in my book, btw) you wouldn’t go out of you way to define this decision of putting a diversified cast of character as:

This is quite literally a way to generalize a bunch of people in a negative way from the get go.

What about this point, too? a straight cis woman can’t wear short hair without you automatically thinking that she’s a lesbian? hahaha

Do you relate to Aloy? do you relate to Lara croft? do you relate to any game that doesn’t have a straight male in it?

Why do you NEED a straight person in a videogame to relate to him/her? i’m really interested in this, tbh.

Coming from someone that didn’t ever found a bisexual character in my young age when i was discovering myself i still related myself with all kind of characters.
even to this day where i can find some bisexual characters.

No one is telling you that Borderlands shouldn’t have a straight man/woman in it.
i want you to know this 100%.

Hell, we still need to get the two extra characters next year.
it’s just…weird that this actually makes you mad.
even because borderlands is FULL of straight characters.
maybe some of them died? fair.
does it mean that Gearbox is going full Dragon age-style on it? nha.

6 Likes

Are we seriously debating the lack of strong male characters in games? My games library is a little aged, I have to admit, but the overall impression is that BL3 is an exception.
Just some examples:

  • Corvo Attano (Dishonored)
  • Geralt the Witcher
  • Isaac Clarke (Dead Space)
  • Commander Shephard (yes, one can play him all hetero :wink:)
  • Gordon Freeman
  • Max Payne
  • Sam Fisher
    and the list goes on for a while…
    So, my question is: Is it reaaally that bad, when one game gets along without the cliche cis-male hero?
    Answer (personal opinion follows): Of course it isn’t!
    Once I concentrate on mobbing or even boss fights, I don’t have the time to listen to the character I play. Out of battle, all I want are well-written characters. The number of standard male hetero heroes in games across the board is that high, it’s almost refreshing to hear something else once in a while.

Just as an aside: mate, if you didn’t notice it without it being pointed out to you, then it can’t be such a forceful feeding…

A part of the problem may be that characters that aren’t the standard hetero folks just don’t stand out when playing. Maybe that’s why some people don’t notice them…

6 Likes

I played BL2 excesively, TPS twice without DLC and Tales as well, but Hammerlock being gay was a surprise for me… Did I miss something or is this first time they mentioned this? Don’t get me wrong, I couldn’t care less about sexual orientation of fictional character, he just didn’t striked me as such… thx

It’s not wildly advertised. Hammerlock mentions that Taggart is an old boyfriend of his during the missions in the Highlands, when you collect Echo Recorders from the stalker heaps.
Hammerlock is an example that gay characters can be depicted without falling back on some of the usual cliches about homosexual people. He’s a hunter, scholar, gentleman and happens to be gay. I don’t really get the OPs problem with that :confused:

4 Likes