IMO there is only one all around “good” vault hunter :
Let me explain bit, i’m gonna go from which one is the “worst”, to the “best”. (worst = worst design, best = best design, i’m not going to talk about power).
Ok so the worst for me is Zane, the character needed a lot of buff at launch, and even that didn’t make him good enough. So they decided to introduce the seeing dead COM, which ruins all build diversity on him.
It’s a shame since he is one of the best character to play style wise.
His trees are well designed except the barrier one which has a crap capstone and offers no damage.
(If there was no seeing dead he would be 2nd or even 1st).
The second worst for me is Amara (or sal2.0).
I don’t feel the character has a true personality, and ties that bind needs to be reworked.
When the character only needs one skill to kill everything in m10, there’s an issue. You can do M10 with white gun as well.
Then comes Moze, she has some issues, like being the vh that is focused the most on some weapons (splash and big magazines), and can’t play with every weapon like other vhs do.
Then there is fire in the skag den, which like ties that bind needs a rework.
It’s not okay to get that much damage and render the weapon choice secondary.
I think Fl4k are the best overall since they can play with everything, has great coms (stalker, bounty hunter, deadeye, red fang).
They also are the most challenging to play, he has low durability and you need to think a bit, unlike other vhs which have crazy survivability/healing.
Again, some issues are due to how mayhem works, because of the scaling you can directly jump into m10 with moze and amara, and that’s not okay.